Is it a bad idea to grab at a job, whatever the salary?

In 1970s weepie Kramer vs Kramer,  unemployed ad-space  salesman, Dustin Hoffman, has to find a job on Christmas Eve so that he can keep his son.  His pitch at interview is that he will take a job at a rate far below his normal salary  because he needs the work, thus helping his future employer to bag the employee bargain of a lifetime.  This being Hollywood, Dustin gets the gig and the floppy-haired son gets to stay with Dad who can thus perfect his French toast-making skills.

I was reminded of this  for the first time in years as I read the increasingly unmissable Redundant Public Servant’s blog. Colleagues of our hero, who’ve been pushed out of work ahead of him, report that at interview, they’ve got the sense that anyone chasing a much lower paid job is an object of some suspicion.  That certainly rings  true to me.

My sense, bolstered from conversations with the odd recruitment consultant, is that applying for jobs that involve a significant drop in salary level or job title makes the applicant look desperate (which, admittedly they might be; but it’s never a good look). Even if they get the job, it devalues their CV in the long term.

More importantly, no matter how much employers know that it’s a buyer’s market out there with Dustin Hoffman-esque bargains to be had, they will  also fear that they are just a holding pen for the applicant – a finger in the financial dyke which will do until something better comes along.

One of the standard job hunters’ bibles, Richard Bolles’ What Color is Your Parachute, lists the fears  interviewers have at the back of their minds during an interview,  which might stop a candidate getting the job.  Number four on the list is the fear that you’ll only stay around for a few weeks, or at most a few months and then quit without advance warning.  It’s a hard one to counter if the job you’re applying for pays significantly less than the one you’ve had to leave.

Bolles’ suggested answer to the question Doesn’t this job represent a step down for you? by the way, is a chirpy and unarguable  No, it represents  a step up – from Welfare.  This does suggest another issue,  raised by Jenni Russell last week, about how to cushion the financial catastrophe which strikes the middle-class unemployed (for want of a better expression) when they lose their jobs and find a safety net of welfare benefits underneath them which doesn’t come close to meeting their needs.  Another blog post, perhaps…


2 responses to “Is it a bad idea to grab at a job, whatever the salary?

  1. At this point for me, being laid off 2 years, EVERY job is a step down.
    I had a great job at $65k/year as a graphic design manager, but company closed the office. Those jobs simply don’t exist anymore. They ONLY want to hire in more entry-level designers at the $30-40k level, a stage I passed 10 years ago.

    I’m trying to switch careers to marketing communications, willing to go lower for the experience, but again they employers do not want to hire me for anything but contract work.

    We are dammed if we do and dammed if we don’t.
    Right now I get NO UNEMPLOYMENT. It ran out last month. I am hanging by a thread, but working 3 freelance/part-time jobs that STILL don’t pay the mortgage. These employers are being picky, petty, and ridiculous. Good people want (and need) to work. By not giving them a chance to do so, they are forcing many onto welfare or even the street.

  2. Jeez, you have my sympathy – the US system of time-limiting the availability of financial support always struck me as inhuman. We Brits are more fortunate, even if our system is about to take a serious turn for the worse. Lots of us are caught in the same trap though: there are no jobs at our old levels of pay, and employers won’t hire us for less.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s