Parental choice

At 7am tomorrow we will find out which secondary school our daughter will go to next year.  The closer the moment gets the more I am convinced that the whole concept of parental choice  in schools is a callous joke.  I don’t feel I have any choice in which school R goes to and it’s an illusion to suggest that I do.   I can express a preference, but I can’t make a choice for the obvious reason that not everyone can go to the one local school which is regularly lauded by OfSTED as one of the best in the country and which is consequently first choice for every parent in the area.  (This isn’t leafy Surrey, by the way, it’s gritty east London which somehow makes the achievement even more remarkable) As a friend of mine said yesterday, the only way you can be sure your child will go to Morpeth is if you gave birth in the playground and never moved outside it.

Schools Ministers have for years been arguing that parents want yet more  choice in education.  The theory seems to be that if schools are pitted against each other in some kind of Darwinian fight for survival, with parents’ votes as the mark of survival, then they will pull their fingers out and standards will rise.  This is evidently not true and runs contrary to another strand of government policy which is about getting schools to collaborate to share resources and expertise.

The continued stress on choice and competition also flies in the face of all of the research, which repeatedly says that parents just want government to make every school good, so that every parent feels happy to send their child to whichever is nearest.  Make every school a Morpeth and all parents will have their choice.  Make it illegal to discriminate against children on the grounds of their parents’ religion (or lack of it) and at least everyone is in with a chance of going to a school they live close to.  As Deborah Orr said in a recent article about schools lotteries:  The worst schools are not compelled to improve because of parental choice. They just end up populated by the children of the parents whose choices are fewest.  The choice is illusory – and I’ll go on believing that it’s a poor way to go about allocating places even if we do get into our first choice.


5 responses to “Parental choice

  1. So how did it go? Did you get the school of your choice for your daughter?

    How nerve wracking!!!

  2. Hi I’m “R”. Although i only got my fourth choice I don’t really mind. I think that it is a fantastic school and the more I see of it the more I like it! My first choice was a beautiful and modern school open and airy. The second is true that you would have to have been born in the play ground to have a 75% chance of getting in. Third i didn’t think was going to be an option after we saw it because it seemed so far away, but then I discovered that one of the people that took us around lives pratically nextdoor to me. I could go on forever but I cant. One of the schools I didn’t want to try out for because i had a exam and a test. People may say that you do have a choice in what secondary school your child goes to but it’s really like the lottery you ethier get a place at the school that you really want to go to or you don’t

  3. Its great that you cominted. Let’s hope your new skool teeches speelung – gramer and ponctuashion like wot mine did!!?!

  4. Pingback: Ignorance And fear | The Line To Take

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s